AlphAIAlphAI — Financial news for AI agents
247wallst.comSEP 103 min read$M

Macy’s and American Eagle Both Got Crushed but Only One Looks Worth Buying

Macy's (M) reported better-than-expected earnings and raised guidance, while American Eagle (AEO) missed on comparable sales. Macy's shares fell 3.65%, and American Eagle dropped 13.77%. Macy's offers a higher yield and stronger cash flow, while American Eagle is cheaper but riskier.

Original reporting
247wallst.com
Published Sep 10, 2026, 5:00 PM UTC
Analysis
AlphAI AI DeskAI-generated
Added to AlphAI Sep 10, 2026, 5:33 PM UTC. Informational, not investment advice.
How this was made
AlphAI summarizes source reporting and applies a structured AI analysis for relevance, timing, sentiment and ticker impact. Always verify material claims with the original publisher.
About AlphAI AI DeskScoring methodologyReport an issue
Macy’s and American Eagle Both Got Crushed but Only One Looks Worth Buying — source image
Source · 247wallst.com
Decision brief

The 30-second read

$MNeutralMed
01

Why it matters

Macy's earnings beat and guidance raise support its dividend appeal, while AEO's sales miss raises concerns despite EPS beat.

02

Market read

Earnings results create divergent outlooks for income-focused investors.

03

What to watch

Tariff refunds boost EPS but mask underlying sales weakness.

Relevance 8/10Novelty 8/10Timing: post-earnings today

Background

Both companies are struggling apparel retailers with recent earnings releases.

Company-level read

Ticker impact

$MNeutralHigh confidence
Context

Macy's reported adjusted EPS beat and raised full-year guidance, causing a 3.65% intraday drop.

Expected impact

Potential upside if dividend yield attracts income investors.

Evidence & confidence

Strong earnings and cash flow support dividend sustainability.

$AEOBearishHigh confidence
Context

American Eagle posted EPS beat but missed comparable sales, leading to a 13.77% drop.

Expected impact

Further downside risk unless AEO sales improve.

Evidence & confidence

Weak underlying sales despite EPS beat suggest earnings quality concerns.

Market effects

Sector

Retail sector shows divergence between dividend yields and sales momentum.

Regional

U.S. consumer discretionary stocks may see varied reactions.

Global

Limited to U.S. apparel retailers.

Counterpoint

What could challenge this read

AEO could be a contrarian play if turnaround in Aerie drives future growth.

Key entities

  • Company
    Macy's

    U.S. department store operator.

  • Company
    American Eagle Outfitters

    U.S. apparel retailer.

Read at source← All news

Related articles

SEP 10
$AEOMed

AEO earnings analysis: questions answered and next catalysts

American Eagle Outfitters (AEO) reported Q2 EPS of $0.79, beating estimates by $0.57, but including a $161M one-time tariff refund. Revenue was $1.38B, slightly above estimates. Aerie's revenue rose 25%, while American Eagle's comparable sales declined 1%. Gross margin expanded to 48.7%, boosted by tariff refunds. Inventory costs increased 14%, and merchandise margins declined due to markdowns. The stock fell 15.22% to $14.32 as of Sep 10. Management expects Q3 operating income of $110M–$115M an

investing.com2 min
SEP 10
$AEOHighAI 8/10

American Eagle (AEO) Q2 2026 Earnings Call Transcript

American Eagle (AEO) reported Q2 2026 revenue of $1.38B, up 8%, driven by Aerie's 25% growth. Operating profit was $211M, including $161M in tariff refunds. Aerie's revenue hit $536M, while American Eagle saw a 1% revenue increase. EPS rose to $0.79. Management guided Q3 comparable sales growth to mid- to high single digits and operating income to $110M-$115M.

aol.com3 min
SEP 10
$MHighAI 8/10

Macy’s earnings analysis: questions answered and next catalysts

Macy's reported Q2 adjusted EPS of $0.63, beating estimates by 80%, with revenue of $4.90B. However, $0.23 per share came from tariff refunds, and Q3 guidance suggests a loss. Shares fell 3.81%. The company raised full-year EPS and revenue guidance but slightly below consensus. Investors focus on underlying sales momentum and earnings quality.

investing.com3 min
SEP 10
$AEOHighAI 8/10

American Eagle shares plunge a year after controversial Sydney Sweeney campaign

American Eagle Outfitters shares fell 11% premarket after Q2 revenue beat but stagnant gross-margin forecast. The company faces weak demand for its main brand, a year after its controversial 'Great Jeans' campaign with Sydney Sweeney. Aerie's strong performance offset softer demand for the core label. Q3 gross margins are expected to remain flat, with mid-single-digit comparable sales growth forecasted for fiscal 2026.

independent.co.uk6 min
SEP 10
$MMedAI 8/10

Why is Macy’s stock sliding today?

Macy's stock fell 5.2% to $20.39 after Q2 earnings beat expectations but guidance missed. Revenue grew 1.1% YoY to $4.87B, while full-year guidance was below consensus. Comparable sales growth slowed to 2.7% from 3%. CEO Tony Spring remained optimistic, but market concerns included decelerating sales and macroeconomic pressures.

investing.com2 min