Lawsuits challenge Money Out of Politics ballot measure on First Amendment grounds
Two lawsuits challenge Michigan's Proposal 2, a ballot measure banning campaign spending by utilities and contractors, citing First Amendment violations. The Mackinac Center and CMS Energy, Consumers Energy, and DTE filed separate suits in federal court. The measure, passed with 80% support, is set to take effect by Dec. 3, 2026, unless blocked by a court.
How this was made

The 30-second read
Why it matters
Legal outcomes could set precedent for campaign finance rules affecting utilities nationwide.
Market read
The lawsuits introduce regulatory uncertainty for Michigan utilities, potentially impacting their stock performance.
What to watch
Potential for settlement or amendment of the ballot measure before litigation concludes.
Background
Michigan voters approved a measure restricting utility political contributions; utilities are now challenging its constitutionality.
Ticker impact
CMS Energy filed a federal lawsuit challenging the Michigan ballot measure restricting utility political spending.
likely pressure as the market prices in regulatory risk
The lawsuit introduces uncertainty about future campaign spending limits for utilities.
DTE Energy joined CMS Energy in filing a lawsuit against the Michigan ballot measure.
likely pressure as investors assess regulatory exposure
Similar to CMS, DTE faces potential constraints on political contributions.
Market effects
May affect broader utility sector by highlighting regulatory risk in political spending.
Could influence Michigan-based utilities and related stocks.
Limited to U.S. utility investors.
Counterpoint
If courts strike down the measure, utilities could benefit from clearer political engagement rules.
Key entities
- think tankMackinac Center for Public Policy
Filed a separate lawsuit opposing the measure.
- ballot measureProposal 2
Michigan initiative limiting utility political spending.

