4 Insurance Dividend Stocks With Two Ways to Make Money and Pay Shareholders

Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) raised its dividend for the 13th consecutive year, with a 1.71% trailing yield and a 96.8% combined ratio. Palomar Holdings (PLMR) introduced a new dividend with a 0.29% trailing yield and a 76% combined ratio. International General Insurance (IGIC) offers a 1.61% yield with special payouts, while Tiptree (TIPT) yields 1.36% and is rebuilding its premium engine.

Original reporting
Published Nov 11, 2026, 4:47 PM UTC
Analysis
AlphAI AI DeskAI-generated
Added to AlphAI Nov 11, 2026, 4:49 PM UTC. Informational, not investment advice.
How this was made
AlphAI summarizes source reporting and applies a structured AI analysis for relevance, timing, sentiment and ticker impact. Always verify material claims with the original publisher.
4 Insurance Dividend Stocks With Two Ways to Make Money and Pay Shareholders — source image
Decision brief

The 30-second read

$SIGIBullishLow
01

Why it matters

Provides fresh guidance and dividend updates that could influence income‑oriented trading strategies.

02

Market read

Income‑focused investors may re‑allocate to these insurers; modest price impact expected.

03

What to watch

Potential regulatory changes to insurance capital requirements could affect profitability.

Relevance 4/10Novelty 4/10Timing: current

Background

The article surveys four Nasdaq‑listed insurers, emphasizing dividend yields, underwriting profitability, and cash positions.

Company-level read

Ticker impact

$SIGIBullishMedium confidence
Context

Selective Insurance reported a 13th consecutive annual dividend increase and raised full-year net investment income guidance.

Expected impact

likely upward pressure as investors value higher dividend and buyback capacity

Evidence & confidence

Guidance lift and consistent dividend growth suggest stronger earnings and cash flow.

$PLMRBullishMedium confidence
Context

Palomar Holdings announced a new dividend, raised net income guidance to $285 million and posted a 76% combined ratio.

Expected impact

potential upside as market prices in higher earnings outlook

Evidence & confidence

Higher guidance and low combined ratio indicate profitability improvement.

$IGICBullishLow confidence
Context

International General Insurance disclosed a special dividend and a 1.61% yield, with a combined ratio of 85.7% and solid ROE.

Expected impact

moderate buying interest from yield‑seeking traders

Evidence & confidence

Yield is attractive but overall earnings growth is modest.

$TIPTNeutralLow confidence
Context

Tiptree reported cash‑rich balance sheet after selling Fortegra and announced a $100 million acquisition of Universal Shield.

Expected impact

limited short‑term move; potential upside after acquisition completion

Evidence & confidence

Current revenue is zero; upside depends on pending acquisition.

Market effects

Highlights dividend attractiveness in the insurance sector, may lift peer valuations.

U.S. insurance stocks could see modest inflows from income‑focused investors.

Limited; primarily U.S. market focus.

Counterpoint

High dividend yields may mask underlying growth challenges; investors should watch underwriting trends.

Key entities

  • Selective Insurance Group

    Nasdaq‑listed insurer with rising dividend.

  • Palomar Holdings

    Nasdaq‑listed insurer launching dividend.

  • International General Insurance

    Nasdaq‑listed insurer with special dividend.

  • Tiptree

    Nasdaq‑listed insurer with cash‑rich balance sheet.

Related articles

$PLMRHighAI 8/10

Palomar Holdings, Inc. (PLMR): Investor Presentation November 2026

Palomar Holdings, Inc. (PLMR) filed an SEC Form 8-K — Regulation FD Disclosure. Investor Presentation November 2026 Disclaimer This presentation contains forward-looking statements about Palomar Holdings, Inc. (the “Company”). These statements involve known and unknown risks that relate to the Company’s future events or future financial performance and the a

$PLMRHigh

Keefe Bruyette raises Palomar Holdings stock price target on earnings beat

Keefe Bruyette & Woods raised its price target for Palomar Holdings (PLMR) to $172 from $161, citing strong Q3 2026 earnings and updated financial estimates. The firm expects lower core loss ratios and faster net investment income growth. PLMR reported adjusted EPS of $3.01, beating estimates, and raised its full-year adjusted net income guidance. Truist Securities also increased its price target to $175.

$PLMRMed

Palomar Q3 Earnings Call Highlights

Palomar (PLMR) reported Q3 earnings, with CFO Chris Uchida noting $425M in crop premiums and confidence in reaching a $500M intermediate goal. CEO Armstrong highlighted growth in earthquake, inland marine, and property premiums, despite commercial rate pressure. The company's adjusted combined ratio was 76.3%, up from 74.8% YoY, with a total loss ratio of 41.5%. Palomar expects continued growth and capital returns, including dividends and stock repurchases.

$PLMRHighAI 8/10

Palomar Holdings Inc (PLMR) (Q3 2026) Earnings Call Highlights: Record Premium, 16th

Palomar Holdings Inc (PLMR) reported record Q3 2026 results with gross written premium up 28% YoY and adjusted net income of $81.3M. Adjusted EPS grew 50%, and the combined ratio was 76%. All product categories grew, with crop and surety leading. Guidance was raised to $280M-$285M for full-year adjusted net income. Challenges include decelerated casualty growth and catastrophe losses.

$PLMRMed

Truist raises Palomar Holdings stock price target on earnings growth

Truist Securities raised its price target on Palomar Holdings (PLMR) to $175 from $168, citing earnings growth and strong fundamentals. The stock trades at $153.07 with a market cap of $4.04B. Truist also increased its 2026 and 2027 EPS estimates, noting revenue growth of 58% and a 23% return on equity. Palomar reported Q3 2026 earnings of $3.01 per share, beating estimates.