U.S. judge says Ethereum has ‘no terms of use,’ clears MIT brothers of $25 million fraud
A federal judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of fraud charges related to a $25 million Ethereum trading scheme, ruling that their actions did not constitute wire fraud. The case involved exploiting trading bots and a relay software flaw, with the judge stating that Ethereum has no terms of use.
How this was made
The 30-second read
Why it matters
The judge’s acquittal ends the U.S. government’s first criminal case over an Ethereum MEV exploit, focusing on the absence of a material misrepresentation and the “trustless” nature of the system.
Market read
Traders may reassess Ethereum’s legal tail risk around MEV tactics after a federal judge cleared the defendants and dismissed the criminal theory.
What to watch
Other jurisdictions or regulators could still pursue MEV-related conduct under different legal frameworks, and the decision does not validate the underlying tactics as lawful in all contexts.
Background
MEV refers to profits extracted by reordering transactions in blocks; on Ethereum, mempool monitoring and relay/builder workflows can enable sandwich-style trades.
Ticker impact
A Manhattan judge ruled Ethereum has “no terms of use” and acquitted the defendants, clearing the U.S. criminal MEV case tied to Ethereum trading bots.
Likely mild support as traders price lower tail risk around MEV-related enforcement.
The ruling directly addresses whether the conduct constituted wire fraud, ending the government’s first criminal case over an Ethereum MEV exploit.
Market effects
Could ease perceived legal risk for MEV infrastructure (relays/builders) and bot-driven liquidity strategies on Ethereum.
Primarily U.S.-legal risk, but can influence global crypto compliance expectations.
Sets a U.S. precedent-like interpretation for how MEV tactics are treated under wire-fraud theories.
Counterpoint
The ruling is fact-specific to the elements of wire fraud (material misrepresentation), so it may not broadly eliminate future enforcement theories or civil actions.
Key entities
- cryptoassetEthereum
The blockchain at the center of the MEV wire-fraud case and the judge’s “no terms of use” reasoning.
- personAnton Peraire-Bueno
Defendant acquitted in the $25 million Ethereum trading scheme case.
- personJames Peraire-Bueno
Defendant acquitted in the $25 million Ethereum trading scheme case.
- judicial_officialJudge Jessica Clarke
U.S. District Judge who granted judgment of acquittal and directed closure of the case.



