UnitedHealth sues CMS over 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings

UnitedHealth Group filed a federal lawsuit in Brunswick, Georgia, alleging that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services improperly calculated 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings for 45 contracts. The company says CMS used 26 measures without statutory authority, which could lower its star scores and reduce government bonus payments. UnitedHealth claims the disputed contracts would gain between 0.5 and 1.5 stars if the ratings were recalculated correctly.

Cowen analyst Ryan Langston upgraded UnitedHealth to Buy and raised his price target to $455, citing the lawsuit as a catalyst for earnings growth. A favorable court ruling could restore bonus payments tied to star ratings, which can amount to hundreds of millions or billions of dollars.

  • 1UnitedHealth Group filed a lawsuit in federal court in Brunswick, Georgia against CMS over the 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings.
  • 2The complaint alleges CMS improperly used 26 measures to calculate ratings for 45 contracts.
  • 3UnitedHealth says the 45 disputed contracts would gain at least 0.5 stars and up to 1.5 stars if recalculated correctly.
  • 4UnitedHealth served about 7.61 million Medicare Advantage patients as of September 30.
  • 5UnitedHealth holds roughly a 30% share of the Medicare Advantage market.
  • 6UnitedHealth shares rose 4.6% after the filing and Cowen upgraded the stock to Buy with a price target of $455.

Sources