German regulator issues preliminary antitrust assessment of PayPal’s surcharge ban

Germany’s Federal Cartel Office (Bundeskartellamt) has issued a preliminary assessment that PayPal’s rule prohibiting merchants from adding surcharges for PayPal payments may breach German and EU competition law. The authority argues the rule limits price competition because PayPal’s merchant fees of 2.49 % to 2.99 % plus a fixed charge of 34 cents to 39 cents per transaction are above average. PayPal disputes the assessment but will respond during the proceedings.

If the regulator orders PayPal to lift the surcharge ban, German merchants could charge a visible fee for PayPal payments, potentially altering pricing dynamics and benefiting rival payment providers. The authority also considers a disgorgement remedy, which could require PayPal to return economic benefits earned from the rule.

  • 1The Bundeskartellamt opened the proceedings on 23 January 2023.
  • 2PayPal charges merchants a fee of 2.49 % to 2.99 % of each transaction plus a fixed charge of 34 cents to 39 cents per payment.
  • 3The regulator’s preliminary assessment states the surcharge ban may restrict competition under German Act Against the Restraint of Competition (GWB) and EU Article 101/102 TFEU.
  • 4PayPal has been given the opportunity to comment on the assessment and has indicated it does not agree with the provisional conclusion.
  • 5The authority is also considering a disgorgement of economic benefits obtained by PayPal under Section 34 of the GWB.

Sources