Ontario Court of Appeal upholds damages award over unenforceable termination clauses
The Ontario Court of Appeal upheld a damages award to three former CIBC employees, ruling that their termination provisions violated the Canada Labour Code. CIBC argued the provisions were enforceable, but the court applied Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc. to find them unenforceable, entitling the employees to common-law reasonable notice. The court also upheld the inclusion of variable incentive pay and annual bonus payments in the damages calculation.
How this was made

The 30-second read
Why it matters
The ruling preserves employees’ entitlement to common-law reasonable notice rather than only statutory minimums, and it rejects CIBC’s arguments on mitigation and exclusion of incentive/bonus components.
Market read
For traders, the actionable signal is incremental legal risk for CIBC tied to termination-clause drafting and damages methodology (including incentive and bonus components).
What to watch
The article lacks the damages magnitude, whether CIBC has reserves, and whether this is likely to drive broader class/industry claims, all of which determine true financial materiality.
Background
The Court of Appeal applied Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc. to hold termination provisions unenforceable when they fail minimum employment standards under the Canada Labour Code.
Ticker impact
Ontario Court of Appeal upheld damages against CIBC, finding its termination clauses violated the Canada Labour Code and were unenforceable.
Likely modest negative bias as investors price higher legal and settlement risk from unenforceable termination-clause drafting.
The article is a court decision against CIBC, but it does not quantify total financial impact or indicate a broader systemic change beyond the clause enforceability finding.
Market effects
Reinforces Canadian employment-contract enforceability standards post-Waksdale, potentially increasing compliance and litigation scrutiny across Canadian financial employers.
Canada-focused legal precedent may affect Canadian bank peers’ perceived contract-risk, but without quantified sector-wide impact.
Limited direct global spillover; mainly relevant to investors holding Canadian banks exposed to similar employment-contract terms.
Counterpoint
Because the decision upholds a specific damages award without new quantified exposure, the market may treat it as contained and not reprice CIBC materially.
Key entities
- companyCanadian Imperial Bank of Commerce
CIBC, the appellant whose termination provisions were found unenforceable under the Canada Labour Code.
- court_caseGhazvini v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, 2026 ONCA 766
Ontario Court of Appeal decision dismissing CIBC’s appeal and upholding damages to three former employees.
- court_caseWaksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391
Precedent establishing unenforceability of termination provisions that fail minimum employment standards.
- court_caseBaker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc., 2026 ONCA 568
Distinguished because its termination provision preserved minimum statutory entitlements.




